Saturday, July 29, 2006

Better or Worse? p.54

With no columns in the Guardian this week, there has been little Polly Toynbee output to factcheck.  So I turn once again to Better or Worse? Has Labour Delivered?, the book Polly co-wrote with David Walker.  The challenge is to open it to a random page, and try to find a factual inaccuracy.

On page 54 (my edition is a Bloomsbury paperback), Polly writes:

In 2003 the child of a father in the lowest social classes was twice as likely to die within a year of birth, five times more likely to die in a road traffic accident and fifteen times more likely to die in a house fire than those in the highest social class.

The sentence bears a truly striking resemblance to one from page 9 of a 2004 report from the Institute for Public Policy Research, written by Will Paxton and Mike Dixon (you can download a pdf version of the report from the Guardian's website here):

The list of disadvantages which are correlated with poverty is long, but to give just a few examples: in 2003, children of fathers in the lowest social class were twice as likely to die within one year of birth (ONS 2001), five times more likely to die in a traffic accident and 15 times more likely to die in a house fire than those from the highest social class (DoH 2003).

As I say, the similarities are startling, and for those interested in this sort of thing, the IPPR report is dated 2004; and Polly's book is dated 2005.  I'm going to assume it is Polly who was handy with the copy 'n' paste.

But the differences are striking too -- for example, I'd always assumed the absence of sources from Polly's material was just laziness, as opposed to deliberate suppression.

And, as ever, going to the original sources is revealing.

The figure about children from social class V being twice as likely to die within one year of birth than those from social class I is taken from an ONS report  called Childhood, infant and perinatal Mortality statistics - Review of the Registrar General on deaths in England and Wales, 2001 (pdf link here -- see Table 20) which was published in 2003, but actually refers to 2001. 

By the time the 2003 figures had come out in 2005 (pdf link here -- again see Table 20), the ONS had moved from a five-class categorisation of social class to an nine-class one (counting 1.1 and 1.2 as two separate classes).  As a result, the chances of dying before one in the top social class (1.1) was 0.32%, and the equivalent chance in the bottom social class (8) was 4%.  A tenfold difference and not a twofold one.

As for the figure about dying in traffic accidents and in house fires, the report that Paxton and Dixon cite, Tackling health inequalities - 2002 cross-cutting review, was actually published on 19 November 2002, according to the page on the Department of Health website from which it can be downloaded (here).  Therefore, the quality of its insights into causes of death in 2003 are likely to be limited.  In fact, the closest it comes to sourcing its claim that "[r]esidential fire deaths for children are 15 times greater for children in social class V compared to those in social class I" is on page 48, where it makes clear that the data it is using cover 1989-92.  Rather than 2003.

7 comments:

Emeka Mordi said...

I'm neither here nor there with Polly Toynbee, but this, I confess is very funny. Someone should tell her about "glass houses" & "throwing stones". Witch hunt or not,(I don't have an opinion on that) on the evidence available (and it seems incontrovertible)she appears to be guilty

Anonymous said...

Stage 2 F Redefine the problem, from Stage 1 findings G Define the parameters H Reconsider the criteria of success and their hierarchy Stage 3 J Subject findings to critical http://buyviagraonlineauviagra-au.com#9,4657E+84 buying Viagra in respect of loss-making companies. In 1991/92 the group reported a revenue surplus of ВЈ32m ( v ВЈ44m), earnings per share (based on revenue profits) of 13.6p ( http://buyviagra100mgcostviagraonline.co.uk#5481 viagra uk 732 To achieve this look:o Paint your nails black

Anonymous said...

Вкусненькое онлайн [url=http://aftertube.net.ua/tags/%E3%F0%FF%E7%ED%F3%EB%FE/]грязнулю[/url] Посмотри про то как [url=http://aftertube.net.ua/tags/%EC%E0%EB%FB%F8%EA%E0/]малышка[/url]
со слабыми нервами вход воспрещен!

Anonymous said...

Therefore, the sturdier the motor the better it is for you. Let’s not forget about a baby gift basket., changing ip program. A poster that is 18x24 is a nice middle ground option for most people. windows 2000 server setup vpn

Anonymous said...

In addition to this it also act as a money saving strategy. There has been great rise in globalization since the beginning of the twenty first century. download cisco vpn client 4 8. Whether it is about building a pool or a spa, you have the facility of controlling its lighting, temperature etc. Although it's a high impact workout, it can't be that much worse than going running, and you have time for a solid warm up and warm down to prepare your legs for the hopping around., cisco vpn download linux. The budget flight companies shouldn't be confused with regular air carriers who give periodic cheaper prices. connect to the internet

Anonymous said...

These awards simply represent its esteem. People to pay attention vitamins, mainly because of its ability to prevent scurvy, beriberi and other nutrient deficiency. pressure switching. He has been wearing two pair of old shoes for 10 years. After menopause, 35 years is the most critical time to maintain bone health., vpn windows vista router. Try to check out this website for more information and tips about brochure mailing the best place to find an easy and efficient direct mailing to your clients plus providing you a better mailing list for your targeted market. maryland reality virtual

Anonymous said...

So make sure that you pick poster sizes that are in between the largest formats and the smallest ones., how to configure samba server in linux. It is absorbed into the blood. First there is the endosteal implant. private number place. Just keep the <a href=” http://www. set up dns server